Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Contrast These with Adam and What do you Have?

I'm back at my daughter's, in town on business for Tuesday's show. Snacks are leftover Dove chocolates from a conference. So glad Idol's only an hour tonight. It's the girls tonight.
Katy Stevens - slow, too slow and kinda flat and gloomy. Song choice, too bad. Add Kelly Clarkson to the list of divas you don't copy. She's just too young.
The lighting is really working for Kara, she looks gorgeous again tonight.
Siobhan Magnus - House of Rising Sun. Showed her versatility while maintaining her strong vocals. Love her style and she takes some risks. She could be the Idol. Simon's off base...
Lacey Brown - good song choice, but it's pretty tame and she has a baby voice.
Man this seems flat and boring and difficult to write for some reason.
Katlyn Epperly - looks like Raggedy Ann tonight. She's not hitting notes and it's too soft. The judges aren't going to like it. Randy sums it up - he just didn't feel it. Needed more guts!
Didi Benami - I just started thinking about Adam. Come out every week in some great getup and just rock out to some great song. So far, it's just so tame. Didi has a great voice but it was just so quiet and snoozy.
Paige Miles - everyone's picking slow, quiet and sad songs. I'd like to see someone come out and just rip. And I'm tired of glittery eyelids. Peanut performance, Simon sez and he's right on.
Crystal - That's more like it! She's brilliant - she took that song and turned it into something wonderful. Her voice is so raspy and deep. She reminds me of Janis Joplin. It's also great that she's so original in her look and she's not letting them doll her all up, although I wish they'd fix those teeth and also her brows. She definitely the best of the night.
Lily Scott - not her best performance. And the outfit was too girlish. Simon's right again, it didn't have the wow factor.
Girls, step it up. You (except for Crystal) all need to pick it up and stretch your voices - everyone (except for Crystal) used their little baby voices tonight and there's nothing new about it.




No comments:

Post a Comment